A Duval County jury awarded $1.5 million to Macy Pagan, a Jacksonville mother who suffered permanent neck and lower back injuries after a cement mixer crossed into her lane. Campione Law, P.A. represented Pagan. The defense initially offered $45,000 before trial and later asked the jury to award her nothing.

The case illustrates two questions that often come up after a serious commercial truck crash: What shows who had the right of way, and what shows how the injuries will affect someone years later?

What happened at Beach Boulevard and Hodges Boulevard?

On August 10, 2023, Pagan was driving on Beach Boulevard near Hodges Boulevard in Jacksonville. She was already in the right-turn lane when a 40,000-pound cement mixer crossed several lanes of traffic and a bicycle lane into her path.

Pagan had more than 170 medical visits in the years after the collision. She received spinal injections and nerve ablations, and her neurosurgeon recommended cervical disc replacement surgery.

What did the jury decide?

At trial, the defense disputed fault and asked the jury to award no damages. After a seven-day trial before Circuit Judge Waddell Wallace, the jury found the truck driver negligent and found that Pagan’s injuries were permanent. The $1.5 million verdict included damages for past and future medical expenses and pain and suffering.

“Macy never gave up, and neither did we. We were prepared to try this case from day one, and in the end, she got justice,” said M. Antoine Pecko, who served as first chair at trial.

The Campione Law trial team included Pecko, Steve Paveglio, Kelsey Alvarez, Kirby W. Johnson and paralegal Nick Joesil.

What evidence matters after a cement mixer or construction truck crash?

  • Evidence of where the vehicles were. Dashcam or nearby security footage, witness accounts, and photos of lane markings can help show whether a commercial truck crossed into an occupied lane or turned across another driver’s path.
  • Records that identify the truck and who operated it. The company name, plate number, truck markings and crash report can help an attorney identify the driver and the businesses involved. Depending on the crash, vehicle data and dispatch records may also be relevant.
  • Medical records that explain the injury over time. Initial treatment shows what was documented after the crash. Follow-up visits, imaging and specialist recommendations can help explain what hasn’t improved and what treatment may be needed in the future.

What should you do after a similar truck accident in Jacksonville?

Get medical attention and report the crash. If you can do so safely, save photos, witness contact information and any dashcam footage before it’s overwritten. Keep your treatment records and bills. If the truck company or insurer disputes how the collision happened, a truck accident attorney can help identify records or footage that may need to be preserved.

Campione Law, P.A. represents people injured in commercial truck crashes in Jacksonville, Duval County and Northeast Florida. If a cement mixer, construction truck or other commercial vehicle injured you, speak with a Jacksonville truck accident lawyer or call (904) 990-8400 for a consultation.

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.